Why You Need 10 Gig Switches When Working With Shared Storage For Video Editing

10 gig switches video editing shared storage

A 10Gbit Ethernet Setup Could Drastically Improve Your Video Editing Performance from Shared Storage

When you are building a scalable editing team or post-production house, the ability to have scalable storage is also a necessary part of that.

You’re here because you have, more than likely, come to a bottleneck in your networking capabilities.

You may also have come from my post on which Synology or QNAP is the best NAS for video editing and want to get established with 10Gbit Ethernet networking.

Which Synology NAS for video editing
Best NAS for Video Editing

You have the NAS and computers set up but you’re still not getting the speeds you thought you would be able to get.

Or, your team can edit but only one at a time. 

Your Guide to NDI

‘It was fine when it was just me and my assistant, so what’s happened now that we’ve expanded?’


How do I know what I’m talking about? Head to the DigiProTips Experience and Background page to find out how I’ve built up my knowledge over a career spanning feature film, broadcast TV and digital content production.


What was it About My Video Editing Storage Workflow That Wasn’t Working?

Well, just like you, I also asked the same head-scratching question when my team expanded and I had increased the storage to match.

It wasn’t for a few painful weeks later, after testing different settings on our NAS and computers, that I stumbled upon the answer…

It’s our network switch and cabling!


I Needed A 10Gbit Ethernet Network!

Yep, that’s right, it was nothing to do with the NAS or computer set up. It was about the bandwidth capabilities of our office network switch and the cabling we were running between it and the NAS and computers.

If you’ve read my article on how a growing post team can scale their storage then you’ll already be familiar with the options and now want to know how to implement the solution to your network problems:

Best ssd for nas

A World of 10G Video Editing Possibilities

So, my next step was to invest in a 10 Gigabit switch and update our old CAT 5 Ethernet cables to CAT 6.A. From what I had read, this would solve all of my problems.

And it did!

But… Only for the editors on the newest computers.

What? Why?

I thought this would solve everything?

Rebuild, Build Better and Build for 10Gbit Ethernet Editing

The next, and final, piece of the puzzle presented itself at this point.

Your computers need to be able to handle 10GbE connections. 

Of course!

My editors who were editing on the newer iMac Pro’s were getting amazing speeds because they have 10GbE network cards in them, not Gigabit Ethernet connections.

10 Gig Switches - read write speed
Write/Read speeds at 10Gbps to a NAS connected through a 10 Gig switch

So, to overcome this particular issue, I needed to do some digging and find out the best way of adapting our older editing PCs to be able to accept the 10 Gigabit connection from the switch and get that blazing fast speed from the NAS.

I found a few options and each is preferable in different situations and setups.

The first, was to get Thunderbolt 3 to 10GbE adapters from QNAP or Sonnet and use those to bridge the gap.

This works because Thunderbolt 3 connections are capable of carrying 10Gigabit speeds whereas USB3.0 is not.

Another issue then arose, a couple of the older Windows PCs didn’t have Thunderbolt 3 ports.

My next move was then to install 10GbE NIC cards in the available PCIe slots within the PC to get those particular PCs running 10G speeds.

I was so nearly there, apart from one very old machine that one of the junior editors was still unfortunately using. It had no PCIe slot capable of taking 10GbE connections and certainly no Thunderbolt 3 ports.

I had to face facts and go with a 5GbE connection instead, via a USB3.0 to 5GbE adapter from QNAP. This was still 5 times the speed with which that particular PC was able to access the NAS before, and so that was plenty for that editor.

Finally, Editing 4K in Real-time, for Everyone!

10GbE Network Attached Storage Setup
How to connect up you 10Gbit network for video editing

Ok, so now I’d cracked it. 

I had a team of 10 post-production staff all working on 4K footage, in real-time, at high speed, through a 10 Gigabit network setup… success!!

I really didn’t look back after that.

The team were all super happy with their new and improved speeds and I was able to deliver versions faster to directors and clients because we had the bandwidth available to ensure there were no bottlenecks anymore.

Learn From My Mistakes, Setup 10Gig Switches the Right Way

So, save yourself the headaches I went through and use the below options to create your own high-speed editing 10 Gigabit network setup.

And don’t worry if you’re thinking, ‘I know nothing about networking, how am I going to set this all up?’

A lot of this is plug ‘n’ play and if you have no need to split your local network traffic up for different departments of your company etc then you really can just leave the equipment in default mode and off you go!

The Future is Bright, the Future is 10Gbit Ethernet Video Editing

So, to save yourself the pain and lost time that I had, and instead get your team up and flying with 4K real-time editing from shared storage then these are the things you need in your life.


DISCLAIMER: This post may contain affiliate links. We make a small commission if you buy the products from these links (at no extra cost to you). As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. But we only recommend products we would use ourselves. For more information, click here to see our disclosures.


10 Gig Switches

At the very heart of this setup is the network switch. It is the brains of the operation and it is what allows your editors’ computers to communicate with the NAS at high speed and deliver the information to each computer at the same time.

There are varying sizes of switches, to accommodate small to large teams of editors.

An important but often overlooked aspect of choosing a switch, is to make sure you have enough ports for not only your editors PCs but also the connection(s) to the NAS and a connection back to the main switch (which is probably a gigabit switch that your router and the rest of the office IT infrastructure is connected to).

This ensures your editors PCs still have access to the internet and so does the NAS for external access and updates as well.

I have chosen NETGEAR switches below because in my experience they are incredibly easy to set up and use. When you are leaving them in a plug ‘n’ play state AKA, ‘unmanaged’, then NETGEAR do a great job of getting you up and running, straight out of the box.

10Gbit Ethernet switches do cost more than Gigabit switches but the investment in 10G cannot be underestimated and for future-proofing your setup you want to put the money in now to reap the rewards later.

NETGEAR XS708T 8 Port 10 Gig Switch

The lowest I would start with for 10GbE switches is an 8 port. Even if it’s just you and one assistant or another editor, you still want a couple of ports spare for expansion in the future.

8 ports should should allow for up to 4 users/Editors to all be connected to this switch at the same time as your NAS and main network switch.

The XS708T retails for around $1,000/£700 and is the lowest entry to 10Gbit Ethernet networking.

8 Port 10G Switch
10gbit Ethernet Netgear XS708T 10GbE 8 Port Switch

Get 2-4 Editors up and editing in 4K in real-time with this 8 port 10gbit Ethernet switch from Netgear.

NETGEAR XS716T 16 Port 10 Gig Switch

Then the next step up is to go with 16 ports. This may seem like overkill but if you have 10 users all connected to this switch then it still gives you enough ports to have two bonded 10GbE connections from your NAS, a connection to your main network switch and also a connection to a backup NAS if you have one.

The XS716T retails at around $1,350/£1,000.

4-10 Editors
10 Gig Switches - Netgear XS716T

The XS716T is perfect for a medium sized post-production teams of 4-10 users, all accessing and editing from your NAS in real-time at 10G speeds!

NETGEAR XS728T 28 Port 10 Gig Switch

If you have a team of more than 10 post-production professionals like I did, then you will be wanting to bond your 10GbE connections to your NAS, potentially have a backup NAS and then there may be more than one other switch this one needs to loop into. 16 won’t cut it, so 28 is the next size up that switches generally come in.

The XS728T is no small-fry when it comes to network switches. At this point, you will want to stop using this as a plug ‘n’ play device and most likely start using some of the advanced ‘smart’ features inside it. Creating VLANs for your traffic would be a good idea at this point to ensure the bandwidth is being used as efficiently as possible.

With two 10GbE bonded connections from your NAS you should still have no issues with this amount of ports and users.

The XS728T retails for $2,100/£1,500.

10+ Editors
Netgear XS728T - 10 Gig Switches

For larger post-production teams the XS728T will more than handle all of your networking needs to ensure your whole team can edit at 4K in real-time.

Cabling

As I mentioned above, once you start to go down the path of 10Gbit Ethernet networking for video editing, you have to upgrade and invest in your cabling. The standard CAT 5.E Ethernet cables you are most likely using right now aren’t capable of carrying 10Gbps speeds.

I suggest moving up to CAT 6.a for the best speeds possible when working at 10G.

There are many different brands, lengths and prices available for ethernet cabling these days, so measure up what you need for all of your connections and go from there.

Computer Adapters

So, a piece of the puzzle that is incredibly important but that I overlooked, is whether or not your PC has the ability to accept 10GbE connections or not. If you are on newer PCs like the iMac Pro then this won’t be a concern but if you are using older PCs and/or you know you don’t have a 10G network card then you will definitely need to invest in one of the below options.

PCIe

For Windows PC users (Macs don’t allow for upgrades such as this) then you should have the option of installing a network card to your motherboard in an available PCIe slot.

This will allow you to connect your PC at 10GbE rather than the standard Gigabit connection.

The QNAP QXG-10G1T is a trusted 10G PCIe card. QNAP are well known, not only for their NAS’ but also for their networking peripherals.

The QNAP card retails for around $110/£80.

10Gbe PCIe
QNAP 10GbE PCIe

QNAP QXG-10G1T Single-Port (10Gbase-T) 10GbE Network Expansion Card. Add 10Gigabit Ethernet to your computer with this expansion card.

Thunderbolt 3 to 10G

For Mac users, predominantly, the best option for getting 10Gbps editing speeds is to get an external Thunderbolt 3 adapter.

My go-to, again, for this is QNAP. I have used other makes in the past but have found that they are unreliable and degrade over time. QNAP adapters just work, as they should.

A QNAP Thunderbolt 3 to 10G RJ-45 adapter will retail for around $220/£190.

Mac 10G Adapter
shared storage for video editing - QNAP adapter

The QNAP QNA series is a cost-effective Thunderbolt 3 to 10GbE adapter that empowers your Mac or Windows computers with blazing-fast 10GbE network connectivity using Thunderbolt 3.

USB-C to 5GbE

If your editing PC is older than both 10G network cards and Thunderbolt 3 then your next option is to use USB-C.

Because USB interfaces can’t carry the same speeds as Thunderbolt this external adapter will only allow your PC to connect at up to 5Gbps. That is still 5 times faster than it could connect before but it won’t be as fast as the other adapters mentioned above.

Again, there really is only one clear winner in this category, QNAP.

Their 5GbE adapter is tried and tested.

It retails for $118/£90.

5GbE Adapter
QNAP_UC5G1T - shared storage for video editing

The QNA-UC5G1T can be coupled with other devices, including a QNAP 10GbE switch, to create a budget-friendly high-speed network environment for improving the performance of various work and entertainment applications.

Everything You Need to Get Your Shared Storage for Video Editing up to 10Gbit Ethernet Speeds!

I hope by now you are armed with everything you may need to get your post team up and running at 10G.

If you would like to learn more or have any the need for some help getting it all configured then my consulting services are always available.

Let me know in the comments below how you get on with your new found editing prowess at 10G speeds.

Remember, we work smarter, not harder at DigiProTips.

Work smarter, not harder. Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required

Please select all the ways you would like to hear from DigiProTips:

You can unsubscribe at any time by clicking the link in the footer of our emails. For information about our privacy practices, please visit our website.

We use Mailchimp as our marketing platform. By clicking below to subscribe, you acknowledge that your information will be transferred to Mailchimp for processing. Learn more about Mailchimp's privacy practices here.

Got any more tips of your own? Let us know below: